Reports from the Gallows: Southern Capital Punishment, 1776-1820
On March 28, 1820, Jordan- a Virginia slave convicted of the murder of his overseer- was ushered before a sizeable crowd eager to witness his death. Slaves convicted of capital crimes faced swift justice, for southern legal norms dictated an expedited trial and punishment. Often, large gangs of slaves were brought in to witness the spectacle. Their inclusion was a political move by the slaveholders to deter future slave resistance. Before climbing to the top of the ladder, Jordan murmured a short prayer- a public act of contrition expected of criminals. Finally, a spectator reported, “…he was turned off; his struggles lasted three to four minutes.” His body presumably remained before the public’s view for the rest of the day, a symbolic representation of white supremacy in the South.
Jordan’s case tested the boundaries of plantation justice. His body reminded the public of the swift and merciless nature of southern justice. Executions were harsh, theatrical, and purposeful. The southern imagination on the subject of capital punishment was closely tied to race and protection of the social order. Southerners embraced capital punishment as a prescription to the ills of society-either civic or theological deviance. Instead of viewing the gallows as a symbol of the wrongs of society, southerners romanticized and mythologized death sentences, imagining the gallows to be a mechanism to produce conformity and order. Moreover, southerners constructed myths that legitimized their support of the institution, including: the guiding hand of god at the gallows, the belief of crime as a contagion, and the threat of slave revolts. Myths served to underpin the existing social order, and planter authority.
Vanessa Varin, Louisiana State University
Discussions about, toward,
around, and alongside the
New England American Studies
Association's Fall 2011 Conference.
See the schedule at the bottom of
the page, and please add your voice
and perspective to the mix!
around, and alongside the
New England American Studies
Association's Fall 2011 Conference.
See the schedule at the bottom of
the page, and please add your voice
and perspective to the mix!
Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts
Friday, September 30, 2011
Thursday, August 25, 2011
Questioning Federal Homeownership Policy
“As a people we need, at all times, the encouragement of homeownership.”
– Herbert Hoover, 1932
“Owning a home can increase responsibility and stake out a man’s place in his community. The man who owns a home has something to be proud of and good reason to protect and preserve it.”
– Lyndon Johnson, 1968
“Owning a home lies at the heart of the American dream.”
– George W. Bush, 2002
Objectives of current U.S. Housing Policy are to ensure a minimum level of housing quality; to increase the supply of housing by stimulating new construction, maintenance, and improvement of existing stock; to maintain incentives for savings and investment; to stabilize rents and asset prices; to reduce racial and economic segregation; to stabilize construction and business cycles; to reduce crowding; to foster community development; and to encourage homeownership.[i]
Federal government intervention to promote homeownership is justified on three grounds: (1) ownership creates positive public externalities, (2) low-income and minority households have inequitable access to ownership, and (3) owner-occupied housing is associated with the stability of the broader economy.
Each of these justifications can, and must, be examined critically: U.S. policy is based on the premise that everyone should be a homeowner, yet by so fervently praising the owned home, other types of housing are left unexplored.
Let me forward a question that the (brilliant) economist and New York Times op-ed columnist Paul Krugman posed in 2008:
Why should ever-increasing homeownership be a policy goal? How many people should own homes, anyway?[ii]
I would further Krugman’s questions by drawing upon those posed by Associate Professor and Chair of Policy Programs at the New School for Public Engagement Alex F. Schwartz’s:
What is the role of housing policy in promoting vibrant communities and the economic interests and social wellbeing of the population? And, based on how we answer that question, what are the relationships between housing policy and energy, transportation, education, and other national programmatic priorities?[iii]
I encourage you to read “Home Not-So-Sweet Home” by Paul Krugman—he is succinct and convincing in arguing what I think are very pertinent issues in U.S. housing policy... namely that ownership has become fetishized to a point that we've come to ignore some salient issues it begets, including financial risk, global warming, and inequality. Senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, Adam S. Posen has weighed in on this in a recent "Room for Debate" article in the New York Times Online; "Problem: Home Ownership" is another recommended read.
What are your thoughts? Do you agree with Krugman and Posen? Should homeownership receive less prominence in U.S. housing policy? Please share your musings below...
What are your thoughts? Do you agree with Krugman and Posen? Should homeownership receive less prominence in U.S. housing policy? Please share your musings below...
Written by Marieke Van Der Steenhoven
University of Southern Maine, American and New England Studies
[i] Richard K Green and Stephen Malpezzi, A Primer on U.S. Housing Markets and Housing Policy (Washington DC: The Urban Institute Press, 2003): 85.
[ii] Paul Krugman, “Home Not-So-Sweet Home.” New York Times (June 23, 2008), http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/23/opinion/23krugman.html (accessed December 10, 2010).
[iii] Alex F. Schwartz, Housing Policy in the United States: An Introduction (New York, NY: Routledge, 2006): 252.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)